A lament on Steve Jobs — the man, not the god

by David Alm on October 7, 2011

I learned of Steve Jobs’s death the way millions of people probably did: by turning on my MacBook. There, on the Apple homepage, was a photo of Jobs and the years 1955-2011. I was shocked, but not terribly so. His cancer and departure from Apple in August were never secret, and everyone following the situation knew why he left.

Jobs knew how to run a company, and w hen he felt he couldn’t run it effectively anymore, he took his leave. It takes a lot of courage to do that.

Jobs also changed the world, and introduced us to our future when he rolled out the Macintosh 27 years ago. He then crafted and delivered that future, with iMacs, MacBooks, iPods, iTunes, iPads… The company didn’t dub its suite of programs “iLife” for nothing.

But w as Jobs a saint? Was he a person of great holiness, virtue, or benevolence? Did he truly deliver unto the world a better way of life that has facilitated peace and global understanding?

The way we communicate now is inseparable from the products and technologies that Jobs helped create. Everything from design and filmmaking to keeping in touch with our friends has been affected by Apple products, and the industry had to keep pace with Apple’s extraordinary R&D team to stay competitive. And the products rock. I write this on a four-and-a-half-year-old MacBook Pro, and it still runs like a dream. (Sorry Bill Gates, you never treated me this good.)

But back to the saint question: On Facebook, scores of people weighed in yesterday with thoughts on Jobs that downright deify the man. No one mentioned that he was a billionaire who didn’t believe in philanthropy, or that his searing temper often inspired more fear than awe in his employees. Lots of people mentioned that he dated Joan Baez (good for Jobs’s post-hippie persona), but no one mentioned that he allegedly did so because she’d once been Bob Dylan’s lover, with whom Jobs had long been enthralled (not just bad for his image, but a bit creepy, too).

I grew up with Apple products and I like them a lot. I’ll also go on record saying that Steve Jobs did a great deal to improve our lives. Somebody was going to dominate the world of personal computing and high-tech gadgetry, and I’m glad it was him. But maybe we should all take a step back from the hero worship and ask ourselves, just who was this guy?

Because he w as not, in the end, a god.

Jeff McMahon October 7, 2011 at 9:37 am

We live in saintless times. Not because there are fewer pure hearts, but because there are more men with machetes.

Only when someone dies can his story be told—and part of the mourning process is the assembly of the coherent narrative that will replace, in our lives, the person we just lost.

In the case of great teachers, the story will be a great story. So great, in auspicious cases, that it overwhelms the reality of the mortal, and we remember the human as a perfect example of his teaching—what you might call a god. That might be what happened with Jesus and Mohammed and all the great saviors and saints of the human tradition.

Surely this happened more readily in ancient deserts, when memories were carried on oral poetry, but it almost never happens now, when stories are spun through the meat grinder of journalism. Even before the funeral is over out of the great cacophony of comment come the machetes to shred the rapidly inflating memory of the man.

And so we see all of our potential saints, these days, chopped to pieces—Ghandi, Martin Luther King—even Mother Theresa’s Wikipedia entry has a section labeled “Criticism.”

Is it better that we forbid sainthood by crystalizing what is human in our potential saints? I doubt it, but ultimately I think it doesn’t matter. What matters is never the teacher, but the teaching. What was Steve Jobs’s teaching?

I would venture that it has something to do with a practical method for making miracles. Help me figure it out?

artemis October 7, 2011 at 2:49 pm

At the Galway Museum I saw a quote from a 22 year old Irishman who was executed in India in 1922. He said something like this: modern man does not live by monarch, land or faith, but by culture. Steve Jobs certainly did create a culture.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: